@JayHawkFanToo Curious as to who you would have thought was our weakest link then?
Tharpe did play “brilliantly at times” last season. But he completely collapsed. He was completely unreliable and opposing teams targeted him as our weakness.
You say … “There is no reason to think that over the summer he could not have corrected the issues he had last season and come back as a smarter, improved player.”
He was junior going into his senior season. That is one reason. The better reason is exactly what we saw – a weak player with no grit, very limited ability to defend, very few leadership qualities, and a propensity in the latter part of the season to let us down when we needed him most. Self had to bench him repeatedly vs. EKU, as just one example.
You refer to Self starting Mason. Self did that because he couldn’t get his junior point guard focused, and Tharpe thought Self didn’t like him. More evidence of lack of mental toughness – given that exactly one year earlier Self had to play the same game with Tharpe.
There is actually no reason to think that this tiger would change his stripes. Don’t you think Self thought this as well? It seems painfully obvious that Self influenced this transfer/trade for Graham. Self seems to have a view on what was better for KU next season, and Tharpe wasn’t part of it.
I was very much in Tharpe’s corner heading into the season. But my opinion (sadly) changed dramatically.
Personally, I think it is as simple as this – Tharpe just didn’t meld with Self’s style of coaching. I say that in part based on Tharpe worrying about whether Self “liked” him last November. But also in part regarding his demeanor. Tharpe had the whipped puppy look – in contrast to multiple players who seemed to take their medicine like a man.
I am curious, still – who would have been our weakest link, if not Tharpe?